Jumaat, 22 Jun 2012

Major MAF = Major RELA?

I received this email from RAFOC and totally agree with its view... 
From: Rafoc Secretariat 
To: Rafoc Secretariat 
Sent: Thursday, 21 June 2012 2:03 AM

To All Retired Armed Forces Officers,

You may wish to know that under Section 22 of the RELA Act 2012, an act which has been passed by Parliament and which will come into force with effect from 22 June 2012, RELA will be using the established Army rank structure.
Many members of RAFOC and other retired Armed Forces officers have expressed their “objection” to the use of the Army rank structure by RELA. They are not against the RELA Act 2012 per se but only objected to the use of the Army rank structure, which has been exclusively belonged to the Malaysian Army since 1933 and used by armies world-wide. 
Although there are one or two organizations such as Civil Defence, Security Guards etc. that use the Army rank structure but their use have not been legalized as such. Their use is therefore “illegal” or not authorized. The RELA Act 2012 "legalised" the use of the Army rank structure by the RELA.
The Army, for that matter the Armed Forces, holds esteemed and sacred the commission and the rank structure conferred to them. Their commissions are conferred by SPB Yang DiPertuan Agong and can only be withdrawn or revoked by him.
Having met the prerequisite to become an officer cadet and a vigorous selection process, those who were successful underwent a period of military training to become an officer, either in our own local institutions or abroad. Not all who applied were selected to undergo the training and not all who underwent the training were commissioned. Their commissions were conferred in a traditional ceremony, solemnly officiated by SPB Yang DiPertuan Agong or one of the rulers on his behalf, befitting the profession.
Having made a Second Lieutenant, they had to attend numerous professional courses and had to pass a written and a practical examination before they could be promoted to the next higher rank as Kaptain and Mejar. Their promotions are also based on the vacancies that existed in the establishment and goes through the appropriate Promotion Board and endorsed by the Armed Forces Council before the consent by SPB Yang DiPertuan Agong. They are not promoted simply on a time scale. Hense, a number of officers left or had to leave the Service before their due retirement age or on reaching the end of their short service commission date to facilitate for the upward movement of the younger officers.
Their commissions and promotions are gazetted in the Government Gazette. A commissioned officer holds his commission, using his last rank in Service, till death unless his commission is revoked by the Yang DiPertuan Agong for disciplinary or reasons unbecoming of an officer. Hense, retired Armed Forces officers still have their last rank before retirement, with their names and they are still referred to by their rank. They are proud to use them or to be referred by their rank even though it is only a Kaptain or Mejar when some of their intake members are Kolonels or Jenerals.
Likewise, the Other Ranks also goes through a vigorous selection process before they are selected for the basic recruit training. Again, not all who applied to join the Armed Forces were selected to go through the recruit training and not all who underwent the recruit training were selected to serve the Armed Forces. On joining the Service, they also had to attend numerous professional courses and must have the proper leadership qualities required before they are promoted. Again, their promotions are also subject to the vacancies in the establishment and promoted through a properly constituted Promotion Board.
With all due respect, RELA is not part of the Armed Forces. They have their roles to play but their roles are not part of the total defence plan per se. We have the Territorial Army as the back-up force to the regular forces in the total defence plan of the country. The Territorial Army is part of the Armed Forces set-up.
Not having to state the shortfalls of the RELA officers in comparison to the Army officers as stated above, and not having to state other not-so-nice comparisons, we see no similarity nor justification to warrant the use of the Army rank structure by the RELA organization. They should use their own or other rank structure as appropriate to their organization.
We hope the appropriate authorities take recognition of this. We are not privy to know if the Army or for that matter, the Armed Forces or the Ministry of Defence or the Armed Forces Council have been referred to on the use of the Army rank structure by the RELA or by the Ministry of Home Affairs before the Act was tabled in Parliament. We are not sure if SPB Yang DiPertuan Agong, as the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces, was made aware or has been duly advised beforehand and consented to the use of the Army rank structure by RELA.
On the part of the retired Armed Forces officers, Kol Abd Malik bin Alwi, (Bersara), President of Kelab Pegawai-Pegawai RAMD, has taken the initiative to convey our objection, in writing to our YAB. Prime Minister. Kol Abd Malik has also briefed our RAFOC Committee on this matter during our committee meeting on 14 Jun 2012. Our RAFOC Committee deliberated on the matter and agreed to support the effort by Kol Abd Malek on this objection. Thus, Jen Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Abd Rahman bin Abd Hamid, (Bersara), our RAFOC Deputy President and Lt Jen Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Abd Ghani bin Abd Aziz, TUDM, (Bersara), one of our RAFOC Vice-President, accompanied Kol Abd Malek to meet YB. Minister of Defence on 14 Jun 2012 to state our case. YB. Minister of Defence has agreed to refer the matter to YAB. Prime Minister. To date, we are yet to get the feed-back. 22 June 2012 is only this Friday!
Please let your objection be made known to the relevant authorities and your peers still serving in the Armed Forces through your net-work. We must protect the exclusive and the sacred use of our Army rank structure by our Armed Forces. RELA should use other rank structure.

On behalf of its members, in particular and on behalf of the retired Armed Forces officers' community, in general, RAFOC has made its objection known to the relevant authorities. We want Section 22 of the RELA Act 2012 rescinded.
(Note: Copy of the RELA Act 2012 is attached) (Not attached with this jotting) 
Lt Kol (Bersara)
Honorary Secretary
On behalf of the Committee

7 ulasan:

Tanpa Nama berkata...

mmg patut saranan rakan tuan, saya perhatikan pangkat rela ni baik pegawai atau lain-lain pangkat aci bagi aje ... pernah berlaku ada pegawai rela ni dari 1 paku tut tut dah naik 2 paku x sampai setahun atas alasan keanggotaan di bawah tanggung jawabnya bertambah!!

TAG berkata...

Salam.Thank you bro for extending RAFOC's letter into your blog. I need a platform to vent my anger and yours come in handy. Ini adalah satu issue yang kita bekas tentera mesti bersuara keras menjaga maruah ATM.
Perkara pangkat ini bukan satu perkara remeh temeh. Mungkin mereka orang awam di KDN ingat struktur pangkat itu bukan hak ATM. Ini adalah satu satu hak yang kita mesti pegang dan kalau setakat bersuara melalui media tiada kesan, kita perlu ke jalanan untuk menunjuk perpaduan kita atas issue ini. Salam

Arunzab berkata...

This must be be some kind of joke where Rela members which include Tow Truck drivers, Workshop Owners, Pasar Malam workers, Burger Sellers , Suspected Tugs and Gangsters with no formal military training will be soon be wearing Army ranks of Lieutenants , Captains, Majors,Colonels etc and there are going to be some 2.5 million of them. In the Army proper I don't think many will even qualify to be a Lance Corporal.

Any way the action of the Retired Armed Forces Officers Club (RAFOC) to take action to prevent this from happening is too little too late I am told that the new RELA ACT 2012 was tabled in the House of parliament last Thursday without any objections from Minister of Defense, or any debated by BN Backbenchers and duly passed.

Now this sacred military ranks which take precedence over all civilian orders and decorations has been relegated to a new low

nur_emyinda12 berkata...

Salam Tn Mejar Nor Ibrahim,

Frankly, I was taken aback and shocked to read this entry Tuan. I'm no military myself, but i'm sure to object such practise... giving ranks to; like, any tom dick and harry on the streets @ no rigorous formal military training and selection, exams, etc etc ???!!! Moreover, the armed forces commissions were conferred in a traditional ceremony, solemnly officiated by SPB Yang DiPertuan Agong or one of the rulers on his behalf, befitting the profession. Easily awarded to “whoever on the streets”, i personally take it as a disgrace put forth to the armed forces and do very much agree to Arunzab with his words “this sacred military ranks which take precedence over all civilian orders and decorations has been relegated to a new low”.

Well,(my imagination of the RELA "officers" having to manage the car parks, plus TOL etc etc)...The ranks - the practise - I would take it as a joke of the year! ;-p. Btw, how would the ceremony be like then for these RELA? …*sighhhh*…I wonder???!!!

RAFOC - Bravo for alerting this to the military personnels (and me... ;-))

Tanpa Nama berkata...

dimalaysia dah terbiasa, politicians dapat pangkat military dengan begitu mudah.Begitu juga lain lain anugerah seperti wing paracute dan sebagainya tanpa menjalani apa apa latihan. So, oleh kerana military sendiri tak perihatin maka apa yang di bincangkan kat parlimen perkara perkara yg ada kena mengena dgn military titak ada yg ambil pot.

Ada yg dapat beret hijau comando senang senang je.

azli berkata...

Akta Pertahanan Awam 1951(Akta 221)...

2. Pertahanan bagi Persekutuan atau mana-mana bahagiannya, termasuk—
(a) Angkatan laut, darat dan udara dan angkatan tentera lain;
(b) Mana-mana angkatan tentera yang bertugas atau menjalankan operasi bersama dengan mana-mana angkatan tentera Persekutuan; angkatan pelawat;
(c) Kerja pertahanan; kawasan tentera dan kawasan larangan; pengkalan bagi angkatan laut, darat dan udara; berek, padang terbang dan kerja lain;
(d) Olah gerak:
(e) Peperangan dan keamanan; musuh orang asing dan orang asing musuh; harta musuh; perdagangan dengan musuh; kerosakan perang; insurans risiko perang;
(f) Senjata, senjata api, amunisi dan bahan letupan;
(g) Perkhidmatan negara; dan
(h) Pertahanan awam.

Jadi pertahanan awam ada akta sendiri...

Muhammad Norfariz Khan Jelani berkata...

Streets huh?.... jgn panggil orang awam sbgai streets people... for your knowledge, we work out here is the same as what military did... yes... we were... the difference is, we "fight" everyday... down here... in the "streets"... futhermore... the ranks is a call, for people who were leading, and as a historian, I dont think so RAFOC is the owner, of that "call"... as, we all know, it comes from british, that were not in objection mode, when nearly all the armed forces use them... even some of the country even use that "call" rank for other civilian protection services.... one more thing, the major rank in rela and above is only given to a person that very successful,as when if they were in military, they will be the same, maybe more... well, that is just my opinion... jgn marah aaa... haha... 6 tahun baru komen... lambat sikit la... ade org baca tak entah...